diff --git a/articles/On the Sensor Pattern Noise Estimation in Image Forensics: A Systematic Empirical Evaluation/On the Sensor Pattern Noise Estimation in Image Forensics: A Systematic Empirical Evaluation.xopp.xml b/articles/On the Sensor Pattern Noise Estimation in Image Forensics: A Systematic Empirical Evaluation/On the Sensor Pattern Noise Estimation in Image Forensics: A Systematic Empirical Evaluation.xopp.xml index 8e7206a..c02b9c0 100644 --- a/articles/On the Sensor Pattern Noise Estimation in Image Forensics: A Systematic Empirical Evaluation/On the Sensor Pattern Noise Estimation in Image Forensics: A Systematic Empirical Evaluation.xopp.xml +++ b/articles/On the Sensor Pattern Noise Estimation in Image Forensics: A Systematic Empirical Evaluation/On the Sensor Pattern Noise Estimation in Image Forensics: A Systematic Empirical Evaluation.xopp.xml @@ -1318,6 +1318,34 @@ values, is it? 316.22368230 502.86465448 347.23647388 502.86465448 ? white should not be undertone, as otherwise quite useless or introduce a factor? + 481.51694432 503.09210330 558.56449425 503.09210330 + 315.04529991 513.03372296 348.20213938 513.03372296 + 447.64846029 512.69656313 495.64796338 512.69656313 + 398.53860133 521.90123665 398.53860133 538.29245675 464.72023426 538.29245675 464.72023426 521.90123665 398.53860133 521.90123665 + ? + 313.58289073 547.20510700 376.00027668 547.20510700 + 376.80900789 558.79224017 564.14877777 558.79224017 + 318.78037815 571.83719687 442.24677676 571.83719687 + 349.92547186 603.30076667 563.92622685 603.30076667 + 316.40485384 613.26374187 558.88365577 613.26374187 + 316.13498197 625.77926308 368.78650139 625.77926308 + 471.41897634 625.07189635 493.38876750 626.02632034 + 330.77893234 637.18725227 360.13238902 637.18725227 + 497.26982895 637.18799128 563.96175890 637.18799128 + 316.10148011 649.12219461 368.03444582 649.12219461 + 395.03890775 650.42537522 440.08708325 647.82295540 + 533.22459954 665.07544612 549.88155506 665.07544612 + 383.32777223 671.38969375 455.77081004 671.38969375 + 511.19189765 670.24325939 561.28525908 670.24325939 + 316.70940241 683.58526084 377.32032661 683.58526084 + 421.58852424 689.67026328 421.58852424 717.24481304 476.95909985 717.24481304 476.95909985 689.67026328 421.58852424 689.67026328 + 343.95467513 725.32497621 343.95467513 725.32497621 + 380.55996540 726.10584617 470.82794274 726.10584617 + 516.48287951 725.23651274 546.13956599 723.98405864 + 2 + 1 + do not monitor CPU times in the following? +because it is insignificant? @@ -1329,6 +1357,182 @@ values, is it? 319.32304762 517.35903459 421.01378198 517.35903459 10 11 + 153.23467735 52.50999441 153.23467735 80.00899445 223.87093947 80.00899445 223.87093947 52.50999441 153.23467735 52.50999441 + 79.08710592 89.42953514 79.08710592 89.42953514 + 118.60305964 90.28527266 275.63877480 90.28527266 + 261.59895888 101.88146346 297.20673544 101.88146346 + 50.53580076 113.25041768 116.24884457 113.25041768 + 48.13709232 105.82463979 61.27206942 105.82463979 + 89.78511341 105.31964854 202.61040917 105.31964854 + so a different approach, right? + 218.87573278 118.60836536 232.96153991 119.65579111 + 49.20558938 128.77530776 89.60792685 128.77530776 + 126.58832614 129.45796497 153.26308046 129.45796497 + 167.47588536 130.04394431 214.79906265 130.04394431 + 236.63181253 129.26790635 294.15506734 129.26790635 + 47.77935387 141.80893294 108.98879485 141.80893294 + 287.33331294 135.40257416 297.94608777 136.00492545 + 47.67868723 148.97836856 147.45419133 148.97836856 + 187.06388008 146.79324394 291.87446484 146.79324394 + 49.33106028 161.25240352 146.37383768 161.25240352 + + 203.55856180 158.86342541 293.05761410 158.86342541 + 49.40653421 172.10859739 164.94784043 167.10041063 + 152.65893048 180.87698879 194.68448232 180.87698879 + 90.14075800 193.69345826 167.37825691 193.69345826 + 117.45404821 213.90478083 117.45404821 229.72417650 223.08775773 229.72417650 223.08775773 213.90478083 117.45404821 213.90478083 + 76.31490292 238.74472244 76.31490292 238.74472244 + 110.90268209 239.28118800 289.61898494 239.28118800 + 138.26937064 252.04626775 138.26937064 267.88934969 210.75405231 267.88934969 210.75405231 252.04626775 138.26937064 252.04626775 + 155.93004209 282.40024008 169.28456476 282.40024008 + 191.21883060 275.81075801 285.32342288 275.81075801 + 95.28233635 287.88802641 137.33053572 287.88802641 + 148.49677934 287.11816583 170.86525380 287.11816583 + 194.72887034 286.96206384 210.24782572 286.96206384 + 232.14527320 288.97316070 291.21262775 288.97316070 + 104.32832135 302.12195799 296.63013460 302.12195799 + 47.75056084 313.94341469 115.52857192 313.94341469 + 85.70064376 343.70089097 160.19466549 343.70089097 + 92.24695049 353.01673837 126.30913701 353.01673837 + 219.00587461 352.62223882 292.98408146 352.62223882 + 48.43392864 368.33696013 121.45278032 368.33696013 + that is? + 241.81609248 370.84167883 298.18877835 370.84167883 + 47.48508514 383.49315923 66.03725633 383.49315923 + 225.12504212 383.30779997 271.71930895 383.30779997 + 71.44932645 396.62562247 82.90389853 396.62562247 + 124.24389716 394.78212965 209.25954008 394.78212965 + 73.13966385 407.24819394 298.06346648 407.24819394 + 47.58257782 418.61070549 90.14284160 418.61070549 + 86.61191136 447.84960408 190.72811203 447.84960408 + 221.31339091 447.14589451 295.22596171 447.14589451 + 47.83351963 459.71341182 74.40197782 459.71341182 + 117.21858775 459.77747844 128.36926646 459.77747844 + 160.98963753 458.50268346 174.18751278 459.03471495 + 217.55502433 458.68250961 294.76455941 458.68250961 + 78.57456349 470.03512978 294.13938640 470.03512978 + 124.46435000 481.91364195 230.89207081 481.91364195 + 45 = 35 + 10 (tables I and II) + 273.38827804 483.33258209 295.62599525 483.33258209 + 49.60109322 493.67516291 294.93202353 493.67516291 + 49.84896528 506.93598678 271.58840032 506.93598678 + 233.26406094 516.03746397 260.64322741 516.03746397 + 49.87339056 528.07039167 78.75631432 528.07039167 + 106.70685855 528.42784589 115.47780807 527.07947188 + 209.29791526 529.80828163 281.56587927 529.80828163 + 243.41180799 540.96140656 294.93579762 540.96140656 + 46.70686804 551.65926246 94.59613490 551.65926246 + seem to make sense + 81.43441515 593.68095813 293.80622134 593.68095813 + 49.40395714 605.33788052 299.85045996 605.33788052 + 46.27731282 618.69958895 152.88958079 618.69958895 + 167.63695199 684.75593099 167.63695199 684.75593099 + 248.27708128 684.27860530 248.27708128 684.27860530 + 74.25542923 682.83501249 99.03902821 682.83501249 + 111.40312558 655.40974307 234.39717850 655.40974307 + 160.43852438 708.01925771 173.39597129 708.01925771 + 161.14943458 725.44196743 172.14720387 725.44196743 + 243.54843038 707.54989060 254.49048224 707.02225528 + 242.05502061 725.67754159 254.21102217 725.67754159 + 80.23765221 707.78768179 95.13896374 707.78768179 + 82.87135685 725.66027903 92.51756137 726.05339530 + 202.84446817 618.01147442 294.99244699 618.01147442 + 313.43334510 55.83370848 351.87519418 55.83370848 + 440.90412687 56.69068716 559.99315783 56.69068716 + 315.43640758 69.79173294 427.44098306 69.79173294 + 483.15861119 69.78125413 559.73937194 69.78125413 + 317.12286991 78.39206552 359.55661191 80.82354628 + 400.97949975 135.98552165 560.25422260 135.98552165 + 564.63577531 145.75864668 383.42763200 145.75864668 + 314.64134481 146.93373194 343.38525723 148.68977506 + 315.78537264 160.29786584 342.88674655 159.01721561 + 444.80254562 157.71750268 561.69894534 157.71750268 + 315.38638218 169.59036805 506.18109796 169.59036805 + 545.87837277 168.43218530 560.49691268 168.43218530 + 315.95310932 182.75256229 398.97056366 182.75256229 + 460.73286883 181.51831820 489.63924416 181.51831820 + 533.41211899 181.07885265 560.51175250 181.07885265 + 471.13474112 192.37659647 558.94842397 192.37659647 + 313.07001669 194.07558410 344.05537726 194.07558410 + 347.88254065 111.21777579 409.13619388 111.21777579 + 419.99013693 117.82541101 556.14199796 117.82541101 + 317.05344072 130.13692713 555.30257647 130.13692713 + 360.36914567 203.52338295 457.04692030 203.52338295 + 527.30617789 207.99718855 562.12169580 209.54483040 + 314.81870759 222.79031504 564.68931020 222.79031504 + 564.28609019 232.21220112 315.63404922 232.21220112 + 314.46470209 244.97915681 327.46962471 244.97915681 + 351.05634907 249.41136931 384.14159482 249.41136931 + 353.86527526 318.59539787 418.09672011 318.59539787 + 447.97578557 317.66488754 510.37089431 317.66488754 + 354.28348002 331.65867826 444.10458461 331.65867826 + satellite guy removed high or low frequencies? + 419.35909683 249.45008215 465.08819925 249.45008215 + 522.81526134 249.96945570 547.77944495 249.96945570 + 314.55478571 260.45790604 328.53931036 260.45790604 + 382.99802147 261.78511400 442.37465963 261.78511400 + 458.24493896 262.94280407 563.67805062 262.94280407 + 314.13093414 272.45026390 368.93588244 272.45026390 + 430.60829328 272.95682792 477.85045432 272.95682792 + 496.85181368 274.12325348 561.35564294 274.12325348 + 315.91839472 285.68238001 376.66610585 285.68238001 + 399.07379731 284.05210151 421.53456395 284.05210151 + 442.68450053 284.22004663 559.01819499 284.22004663 + 315.33381761 297.01485737 384.04665734 297.01485737 + 411.50332790 296.91846373 561.07703607 296.91846373 + 317.35401000 307.60855054 435.07060673 307.60855054 + 469.90309304 343.41309334 558.86672386 343.41309334 + 316.48443970 353.50477025 358.49101631 353.50477025 + 518.04568058 328.57578721 561.71307924 330.36402471 + 317.12612914 339.98749041 452.79109483 339.98749041 + hence amplitude and not frequency filter, right? + 431.47653714 351.69476033 474.85048032 351.69476033 + 498.51496873 353.20312088 560.56180606 353.20312088 + 313.79254263 367.08270588 352.47339113 367.08270588 + 336.60757355 379.36915246 336.60757355 401.35391334 538.14906955 401.35391334 538.14906955 379.36915246 336.60757355 379.36915246 + 342.33176780 414.41761060 395.31566669 414.41761060 + 431.64802573 415.31607815 559.33551329 415.31607815 + 315.65989226 426.84517049 343.10754345 426.84517049 + to check + 425.07214906 426.52802083 529.31286866 426.52802083 + 544.92667744 424.92940613 564.18582725 424.92940613 + 314.78486465 437.59206644 558.19222995 437.59206644 + 315.23873145 448.26670980 359.18667747 448.26670980 + 414.73098941 451.69879329 456.31481361 451.69879329 + 524.96851371 450.57871702 560.49576108 450.57871702 + 317.86430697 465.87650315 559.68555635 465.87650315 + 317.03843310 478.48959284 354.51183115 478.48959284 + camera specific noise should not sum to 0 in my opinion + 395.42038932 480.85467625 566.58853377 480.85467625 + 315.19211688 495.06537635 563.86755727 495.06537635 + 315.46244353 507.37560393 359.28353623 507.37560393 + 527.32232245 539.43303586 566.21185026 539.43303586 + 405.57903205 542.92143583 422.64741898 542.92143583 + 444.26534105 541.52548084 489.57148843 544.15461877 + 526.75479946 541.99545431 564.04174864 541.99545431 + 316.02837481 553.91794715 562.23889128 553.91794715 + 315.00130030 565.10372124 563.03419212 565.10372124 + 316.16871121 576.94189096 392.28629863 576.94189096 + 316.45548560 589.17150944 355.37327551 589.17150944 + 398.62356872 588.68565669 473.41507799 588.68565669 + 542.65817716 587.19427447 500.52219811 587.19427447 + 315.82812162 599.89115671 332.59727982 601.74620843 + 352.02115712 601.62417677 466.31035238 601.62417677 + 478.12821618 598.74415388 564.12288413 598.74415388 + 316.57236313 611.61515862 450.41124434 611.61515862 + 397.81842507 620.08551991 397.81842507 638.08573876 449.23479603 638.08573876 449.23479603 620.08551991 397.81842507 620.08551991 + 342.51799871 645.55113904 354.37870692 645.55113904 + 418.31352809 646.73461872 480.24045775 646.73461872 + 489.19319030 651.02992459 541.79656761 651.02992459 + 345.23115658 657.46269830 559.60337646 657.46269830 + 316.04739962 669.60687567 422.55961068 669.60687567 + ? + 456.89088024 670.06688196 527.39794529 670.06688196 + 314.82154994 681.81413431 560.12778257 681.81413431 + 314.35396405 692.26883645 386.01331960 692.26883645 + 393.64562458 701.13544059 393.64562458 719.49690347 497.01939877 719.49690347 497.01939877 701.13544059 393.64562458 701.13544059 + 1 + 2 @@ -1342,6 +1546,186 @@ values, is it? 12 13 14 + 384.04169532 54.64712116 504.89349630 54.64712116 + 438.25278070 83.30938228 438.25278070 83.30938228 + 525.38584682 86.31318014 525.38584682 86.31318014 + 351.63061792 102.22292471 366.11964115 100.79407424 + 339.94957343 116.96806283 376.71497335 116.96806283 + 347.15277619 131.29109268 369.13859821 132.97221139 + 345.85041039 145.38825028 369.64923411 145.38825028 + 433.07488656 131.30412960 443.30439133 131.30412960 + 523.38638465 129.78108358 532.13605442 129.23948283 + 432.59490801 102.84850749 446.43841409 102.21525036 + 520.98148937 102.62471963 532.63551256 103.44382870 + 74.93267650 76.08527876 88.83500993 76.08527876 + 76.08364914 81.78502877 112.01773712 81.78502877 + 56.18911621 241.72608466 56.18911621 290.46861696 277.68765795 290.46861696 277.68765795 241.72608466 56.18911621 241.72608466 + 60.38548927 306.24751859 60.38548927 331.60397245 246.29222880 331.60397245 246.29222880 306.24751859 60.38548927 306.24751859 + 139.15080302 81.91143765 292.96979774 81.91143765 + 50.60013266 93.63665230 291.83785533 93.63665230 + 47.69783521 105.58252822 96.71848621 105.58252822 + 127.66552080 104.67924763 294.54819698 104.67924763 + 48.84916788 116.10040638 86.94540455 118.28467829 + 130.82189612 116.65489246 254.21216597 116.65489246 + 145.05645303 128.09054720 218.71884794 128.09054720 + 155.53470879 140.30341475 294.53467138 140.30341475 + 49.62478896 152.44421919 298.08851519 152.44421919 + 47.88277759 163.19547342 77.12450906 160.83958028 + 114.76751372 163.56801105 294.70508479 163.56801105 + p + 140.83470723 174.73705316 276.26023470 174.73705316 + 66.04019748 184.28868314 229.72993319 184.28868314 + 48.72782786 197.82468461 112.18309036 197.82468461 + 157.48266753 196.59883493 157.48266753 196.59883493 + 196.01753600 198.76690543 295.68476829 198.76690543 + 50.18229741 209.91294343 253.42330168 209.91294343 + 81.04460549 341.66771851 81.04460549 341.66771851 + 113.66001011 340.28262131 147.84357839 340.28262131 + 188.05174908 340.99893198 271.98861736 340.99893198 + 81.47345012 226.02089471 253.01402514 226.02089471 + 153.66951935 236.19882753 194.40596832 236.19882753 + to investigate + 3 + 49.24878366 351.99495063 146.08741554 351.99495063 + 197.36971876 353.61418186 239.15610362 353.61418186 + 249.47644023 351.89181114 294.56868960 351.89181114 + 49.61858316 364.57978734 293.16945985 364.57978734 + 211.88453160 376.74306532 294.56644839 376.74306532 + 49.12970805 388.56713697 143.83369858 388.56713697 + 251.01564977 388.59474569 295.88996805 386.76938707 + 48.36778710 399.30376256 294.49763170 399.30376256 + 154.17947524 393.23350245 242.23948926 393.23350245 + 117.79251552 416.14837574 177.37797065 416.14837574 + 140.47749935 427.47768861 160.99946025 427.47768861 + 188.18727244 426.79044574 230.74715063 426.79044574 + 46.58863566 439.73628013 290.98130351 439.73628013 + 48.41660924 450.52069513 296.88687942 450.52069513 + 47.85213703 463.00432515 121.99726640 463.00432515 + 225.32753130 460.79149708 274.80100112 460.79149708 + 186.14246528 475.07064102 235.68084586 475.07064102 + 241.00170172 486.05735570 298.97059441 486.05735570 + difference? + why mentioning these models if do not improve +performances? Or reproducibility issue? +or comparison protocol (like wavelet specific is not +appropriate?) + 106.68116369 541.27634867 271.98055193 541.27634867 + 179.26516663 552.08555845 183.99696306 552.08555845 + 205.82717577 551.97724588 301.84314339 551.97724588 + 300.41908581 546.65769838 303.29539470 550.98301002 + 303.29539470 550.98301002 307.63767518 537.91408282 + 98.40879118 559.03261790 147.18277653 559.03261790 + 204.45257633 557.35372570 238.74271390 557.35372570 + 116.09722295 569.58775930 148.07019798 569.58775930 + 102.09350294 580.68947555 118.13808871 581.47491223 + 227.82535256 581.44165670 296.51355432 581.44165670 + 49.86937337 592.64274160 294.36708693 592.64274160 + 48.72155574 604.26258077 295.28813308 604.26258077 + 47.53893824 618.51349067 107.07809977 618.51349067 + 155.79292702 614.01264484 168.16083541 615.49512103 + 47.25595365 624.85136772 168.69868549 624.85136772 + 207.90141075 631.41204728 261.81964103 631.41204728 + 198.42625899 643.93495861 221.53939790 643.93495861 + to check + 217.03267578 648.09629494 293.99488591 648.09629494 + 241.36988108 661.38804360 275.72726541 661.38804360 + 98.46364858 666.09240186 228.79105879 666.09240186 + 49.16934939 673.50626082 290.61723506 673.50626082 + 49.61966325 684.86270869 117.05666703 684.86270869 + 195.91699253 689.10954298 298.39208090 689.10954298 + 49.64202309 702.39113497 110.91910522 702.39113497 + fiable + 274.29750862 696.13513662 297.91743117 696.13513662 + 50.07624924 709.11809214 294.64452655 709.11809214 + 173.86767235 718.90978719 237.76734309 718.90978719 + 156.92336841 730.04119655 160.55257850 730.04119655 + 185.35695281 732.15044931 194.42962749 732.15044931 + equivalent? + 262.29192435 737.14817622 290.81323474 737.14817622 + 350.84700035 192.92043320 437.70043641 192.92043320 + 455.05388694 191.52356866 519.84901391 191.52356866 + 313.87015780 203.24271962 373.86999021 203.24271962 + 401.24467226 204.76413603 413.88646971 203.74572122 + 481.48465520 202.29720167 529.21193412 202.29720167 + 556.35429780 203.27123789 562.88640148 203.27123789 + 369.98846154 214.75576214 395.45506136 214.75576214 + 440.15833154 213.71498750 564.20726529 213.71498750 + 563.28766659 226.54612350 314.14507375 226.54612350 + 314.49782497 237.86736410 440.83998589 237.86736410 + not mandatory in my opinion + 506.02939011 232.10710988 562.94544409 232.10710988 + 315.55184498 241.80942243 521.70607409 241.80942243 + 550.27090603 255.65889745 550.27090603 255.65889745 + 439.61692029 267.14393333 531.84167271 267.14393333 + 538.88717159 271.27246892 566.15116682 271.27246892 + 314.64126901 284.68153094 401.83057477 284.68153094 + 406.42184634 285.04717113 544.61145274 285.04717113 + 554.56903531 275.90423350 561.95236740 277.53375405 + 313.86295717 289.61276575 398.65494495 289.61276575 + so an explanation of why it is worst and not why they +have not achieved improvements as authors, right? + 406.18240659 293.78575573 497.67866483 293.78575573 + 542.97905978 289.12026190 556.50630701 289.12026190 + 314.20434262 301.51816658 552.67968174 301.51816658 + 482.55804111 312.18879275 562.10833000 312.18879275 + 315.55980356 323.73232424 398.10233319 323.73232424 + 463.02441111 322.62141928 485.73833009 323.83048014 + why those? + 440.83549354 363.14282669 466.80710776 363.14282669 + 513.05068233 362.44914115 546.15987263 362.44914115 + 407.40624767 372.61718259 474.63797079 372.61718259 + 505.86063018 374.36157206 562.04852982 374.36157206 + 317.93305400 386.19540246 457.13000445 386.19540246 + 540.22012110 386.25759313 548.66865312 387.07550841 + 314.31371634 397.57102673 345.12174884 397.57102673 + 366.47993772 398.04393730 396.66507432 396.09963572 + 512.02569221 397.61790659 547.65376686 397.61790659 + 317.23125828 410.26781422 367.25181275 410.26781422 + 393.82473067 408.33742122 465.35032981 408.33742122 + rétrécir + 481.03404763 444.15915077 557.98168106 444.15915077 + 317.57904850 454.75303343 561.05010044 454.75303343 + 315.43311045 466.09201030 420.79213891 466.09201030 + 401.08921455 504.11470584 417.55538065 504.11470584 + 483.45137347 498.26141196 559.90886292 498.26141196 + 314.68250207 510.78318635 556.94678963 510.78318635 + 314.61042002 522.19621597 366.04581678 522.19621597 + 374.59871898 521.70469747 409.77028888 520.32234788 + 511.20686737 522.20726325 562.41964149 522.20726325 + 317.71832376 532.61749205 559.05681545 532.61749205 + 314.96760895 544.48351682 413.78416690 544.48351682 + 424.03969303 543.74634329 457.41728388 545.26012326 + 483.89576577 544.83375147 523.02127394 544.83375147 + 552.81901798 545.92680645 564.78691266 545.32106329 + 315.43189771 556.54191200 426.69897741 556.54191200 + 312.82428586 572.68472946 381.41116374 572.68472946 + 439.84722661 563.09506880 446.51352798 562.75324752 + 517.50495148 560.37922018 541.32640249 561.47136561 + 437.82957340 568.75811457 544.82491426 568.75811457 + 314.02087826 579.82246337 330.58421226 581.08814388 + 493.21746840 579.22649790 561.10723480 579.22649790 + 315.20170508 591.05979773 336.43810637 591.05979773 + 404.23543320 589.83671461 446.56375473 589.83671461 + 394.48392900 602.31285977 563.03064395 602.31285977 + 437.95713816 615.17029701 475.09587682 615.17029701 + 340.96671865 662.28768599 393.87238255 662.28768599 + 531.37316708 657.87207282 564.95798436 655.96083727 + 314.18793278 670.60719417 392.07709561 670.60719417 + 554.57494740 668.51255111 561.50270728 669.04253611 + 313.70674149 681.57369026 503.60940592 681.57369026 + 350.09301905 692.83325181 560.44920319 692.83325181 + 312.90390962 702.80056633 374.01058718 702.80056633 + 472.75927807 703.34036692 562.60634831 703.34036692 + 315.64446776 715.92397195 332.47699147 714.92556730 + 370.15729726 717.80621551 396.72790926 715.13760678 + not mentioned elsewhere + 436.67917870 715.63714071 533.18035297 715.63714071 + 317.32327469 727.89230246 474.39532629 727.89230246 + + benchmark computational and storage requirements? + 1 + 2 + is not it the original image size? @@ -1355,6 +1739,181 @@ values, is it? 15 16 17 + 51.08390101 57.75068558 101.59917394 57.75068558 + 139.09740469 57.29530286 184.23791111 57.29530286 + 226.71973438 57.17224795 260.77235514 57.17224795 + 159.04467274 44.89131554 162.38148302 48.22812583 + 162.62724931 48.23702943 167.88196114 39.13560156 + 382.53820467 55.12973363 502.69998683 55.12973363 + 442.43452512 84.26844878 442.43452512 84.26844878 + 528.41780291 84.42589614 528.41780291 84.42589614 + 435.88699618 122.67861378 447.36494513 122.09744749 + 524.41899228 123.08245519 533.80599322 122.47032621 + 349.75633295 121.64460393 359.88518252 121.64460393 + 351.21294373 152.94742924 357.82777958 153.48527808 + 435.40948100 154.58955087 447.32456650 154.58955087 + 519.17379123 155.08123991 533.29531726 154.26214979 + 90.29487981 72.44977759 271.10032505 72.44977759 + 112.37127813 85.66902732 144.85895272 85.66902732 + 73.15120380 152.28901729 88.75485547 153.02086614 + 85.40714246 163.63742129 188.22953833 163.63742129 + 283.88948106 164.45944851 299.35040659 164.45944851 + 47.91543622 175.29805770 299.57577265 175.29805770 + 48.64194145 186.58208243 116.90586920 186.58208243 + 199.40309966 182.76108935 294.44645268 182.76108935 + 50.29217327 192.24880431 144.06056591 192.24880431 + same model? + + 158.56427731 197.58378578 292.57264560 197.58378578 + 49.73547016 210.36548381 299.95069525 210.36548381 + 48.25702064 222.50983172 81.65707555 224.06910826 + 151.75987552 215.95440104 296.46976876 215.95440104 + 48.36338146 227.88216170 120.52489807 227.88216170 + 263.71656815 228.16683276 281.81335601 228.16683276 + 64.46031388 239.08667637 295.13236929 239.08667637 + 48.82176761 251.72428608 290.82311899 251.72428608 + 50.49090107 264.16313958 111.39939007 264.16313958 + 106.04138810 246.69445955 109.88778233 251.40222862 + 109.88778233 251.40222862 116.86705861 244.42295234 + 187.51325597 263.20356146 198.13804447 263.72714170 + 247.84621857 263.51514012 296.67692403 263.51514012 + 49.99205877 273.61479456 173.15226968 273.61479456 + 256.81365043 274.66790502 297.02050005 274.66790502 + 48.47530382 287.39989978 236.63187436 287.39989978 + 47.89226157 285.20560385 295.00720670 285.20560385 + 49.21450489 296.41766022 69.18735549 296.41766022 + 81.45305151 302.78809167 290.02279215 302.78809167 + 296.87410409 314.89529951 45.82627068 314.89529951 + 47.53841714 328.31419606 70.10817335 328.31419606 + 144.28001714 327.08904750 210.92812204 327.08904750 + 219.06992228 320.40796590 299.44949512 320.40796590 + 50.00577786 334.07509455 297.81529391 334.07509455 + 48.17803167 343.84005254 294.71287023 343.84005254 + 47.22919764 356.28485603 276.31756703 356.28485603 + such threshold in signal course? + 48.24517750 390.33576224 155.59540985 390.33576224 + 249.19902665 396.71949589 274.58362893 396.71949589 + 96.21098020 400.44005919 117.95490358 400.44005919 + 245.29289565 402.39593862 278.84544325 402.39593862 + 48.07796192 413.51904831 177.35829955 413.51904831 + still have worsening methods... + 62.83399572 446.11828943 126.37334921 446.11828943 + 162.73376172 444.18390766 297.13911262 444.18390766 + 47.98073452 456.74662139 130.84855709 456.74662139 + 240.54330610 456.57662031 296.80611795 456.57662031 + 48.04328522 467.50596685 148.98265450 467.50596685 + 178.05963029 467.25676835 293.37888588 467.25676835 + 49.05301191 479.44968259 188.16148057 479.44968259 + 277.73734226 483.78538776 296.76299574 483.78538776 + 46.33929505 496.23362102 93.57964589 496.23362102 + 108.39401253 503.78721001 241.00541334 503.78721001 + 253.36762046 501.84709617 272.95165484 502.79740822 + 109.05870607 515.74244675 294.72714904 515.74244675 + 46.53531314 531.27288889 139.07737560 531.27288889 + 205.53092687 531.01967321 280.82835907 531.01967321 + 47.58396110 543.14330984 62.83726964 543.14330984 + 49.08243973 548.97176157 145.32930712 548.97176157 + 156.40444963 553.77493894 297.45512937 553.77493894 + 108.24890097 559.53083488 183.57250675 559.53083488 + 229.66892117 558.70837183 263.74734135 560.60907173 + 48.15047033 572.57080798 79.13516418 572.57080798 + 122.75365188 571.30510853 185.58976724 571.30510853 + 211.37882029 570.77104949 254.17485790 570.77104949 + 277.85800959 577.83780039 296.66708053 577.83780039 + 49.03317229 588.41695966 297.01932250 588.41695966 + 49.40833436 599.87667966 63.28736931 599.87667966 + 110.25050437 596.39320644 179.83291557 596.39320644 + 157.71852592 612.24445540 295.76811368 612.24445540 + 85.62445924 623.21820896 88.50496081 626.09871053 + 88.50384734 626.09982357 91.79907157 621.27803827 + 115.07086850 623.73731723 250.92742837 623.73731723 + 283.02078242 624.07292323 297.50825183 624.83385883 + 45.73943556 636.32740282 52.05695188 636.32740282 + 52.69068274 632.42356465 56.72507015 626.23709023 + 111.20110066 628.91987283 190.80530455 628.91987283 + 138.91401612 641.65389513 191.53398228 641.65389513 + 173.36277585 658.31830318 176.42859383 661.88227181 + 176.69823831 661.88227181 182.52117587 654.87852638 + 130.68703598 659.30819972 175.68095196 659.30819972 + 222.01730892 655.24454556 222.01730892 655.24454556 + 273.48777932 654.34943199 297.45669338 654.34943199 + 51.12405398 666.82174945 101.14595523 666.82174945 + no ambiguity with dimensions + 129.68781652 665.48122033 207.40294171 665.48122033 + 48.46710837 677.46893568 139.09230747 677.46893568 + 140.86625734 692.05205972 156.93628287 692.05205972 + 141.20502783 691.60342284 62.50302275 598.68963756 + 204.58686800 694.36531757 296.31877697 694.36531757 + 47.43756101 707.37290680 117.11370362 707.37290680 + ? + ? + if less than a given threshold could consider sparse matrix + 1. + 2. + 145.99630522 718.38046541 295.17371838 718.38046541 + 50.83539416 729.18034280 292.04542621 729.18034280 + 87.64036915 739.91158687 101.60499516 739.91158687 + 185.12145445 741.62344088 274.96745593 741.62344088 + 445.04683633 195.88396439 562.95615094 195.88396439 + 311.43945395 208.22955084 373.08006753 208.22955084 + seem incorrect, no? + 428.21351676 207.85526990 564.29497212 207.85526990 + 313.87982179 219.43542983 457.71096831 219.43542983 + 538.78916728 218.78110140 563.02584029 218.78110140 + 314.44029576 230.65307616 546.42873854 230.65307616 + 337.43693404 252.06443985 560.66123298 252.06443985 + 426.89690130 264.58515310 563.08285704 264.58515310 + 378.10462784 275.75180763 554.25828418 275.75180763 + 317.47191077 286.32532009 385.85793516 286.32532009 + ? + this method or in general? what about practice? + 403.01344912 281.60169069 561.84554355 281.60169069 + 564.02171353 292.86161227 322.55899770 292.86161227 + 312.53588185 304.33950437 351.16485113 306.59081789 + 390.38969113 339.10971518 427.96341227 339.10971518 + 455.37689185 351.21821156 516.08883423 351.21821156 + 543.08218032 351.22118655 560.40961113 351.22118655 + 316.11565397 361.20184118 362.76452793 361.20184118 + 511.10325416 370.18882842 561.50586204 370.18882842 + 433.92645529 380.44214043 450.94734526 380.44214043 + 313.86261609 385.74396113 464.18540762 385.74396113 + 444.62287106 397.72420251 375.30892619 397.72420251 + 312.83080432 413.99093563 487.11543153 413.99093563 + 556.25292057 413.30497182 561.35300264 413.30497182 + 314.87350814 427.36928130 393.86319868 427.36928130 + 478.87204081 397.59198434 509.56187729 397.59198434 + 388.34062045 453.92907341 438.44894995 453.92907341 + 470.10929622 459.86525028 481.25154218 459.86525028 + 500.37898333 459.31387184 553.59973612 459.31387184 + 404.75759225 466.12729336 410.79315671 466.40032972 + 461.95454972 466.06919568 563.59509886 466.06919568 + 388.56084590 475.79394387 534.05798172 475.79394387 + 386.80897157 490.94622052 563.03673561 490.94622052 + 314.61220122 500.84573547 559.05706351 500.84573547 + 317.26638975 511.27106664 364.27257356 511.27106664 + same + 513.58455188 517.51596086 561.98262660 517.51596086 + 401.03774902 530.35100037 314.69878416 530.35100037 + 372.84146313 536.06272616 489.01781509 536.06272616 + 451.78677357 524.01751950 488.37642248 524.01751950 + order of magnitude? + 397.16964869 558.06935420 504.15785247 558.06935420 + 544.39765884 546.59949648 558.19417136 546.01306237 + 389.78673348 574.08030546 558.49207497 574.08030546 + 313.89945297 586.74127932 538.82614142 586.74127932 + 365.41837600 597.15056067 560.44613127 597.15056067 + why? + 426.75235822 605.33409072 500.64082722 605.33409072 + 355.55279873 615.43925933 532.69868898 615.43925933 + 5 + 3 + 4 + 379.37269592 667.66757663 477.50398199 667.66757663 + 533.05871986 668.73078691 562.74678737 668.73078691 + 314.17133344 681.93967153 333.87000936 680.53570111 + 422.32041100 679.69461119 562.27439002 679.69461119 + 315.18881975 690.71175799 351.13784860 690.71175799 + 366.69974629 697.20429689 387.67733415 697.20429689 @@ -1369,6 +1928,34 @@ values, is it? 397.08761462 205.46759358 481.59170146 205.46759358 + 343.04228006 223.67191796 377.76964715 225.03709027 + 514.58722005 225.44687219 565.36276346 225.44687219 + 315.17779142 235.25128204 342.26230071 236.43902525 + 347.85745216 240.52719943 562.35463743 240.52719943 + 313.99404646 252.60600270 364.13456683 252.60600270 + 315.67694637 260.51503732 356.80381270 258.86969435 + 379.39115226 258.23266636 504.46969796 258.23266636 + 450.96609173 270.45559584 562.04184187 270.45559584 + 314.57210511 281.41420913 375.81537351 281.41420913 + 447.69113347 282.04361961 556.89440046 282.04361961 + 400.22601112 292.93358063 481.68608842 292.93358063 + 381.32838586 304.35041900 495.44366036 304.35041900 + 530.04412107 304.84851281 561.09945159 304.84851281 + 315.18703854 321.56357157 557.72129785 321.56357157 + 315.03798559 333.09796964 399.67586797 333.09796964 + 434.43921563 328.27076492 560.54750932 328.27076492 + 315.03195980 339.80497349 341.08641971 339.80497349 + 315.43235249 351.09239010 426.21611105 351.09239010 + 315.38793600 366.94030404 543.65694738 366.94030404 + 497.50324292 396.72609015 561.38935325 396.72609015 + 382.15596514 408.66700143 397.89360001 408.66700143 + 425.73851012 406.75443945 462.36385732 406.75443945 + 488.09562545 413.54972677 504.06919931 413.54972677 + 357.75217301 424.30444866 562.39861752 424.30444866 + 314.31701347 437.58757553 410.65187205 437.58757553 + do they provide the MATLAB code? +No interesting occurrences of code, source (code), git, +implementation, web